Like every other website on the planet, SmallNetBuilder uses cookies. Our cookies track login status, but we only allow admins to log in anyway, so those don't apply to you. Any other cookies you pick up during your visit come from advertisers, which we don't control.
If you continue to use the site, you agree to tolerate our use of cookies. Thank you!

Router Charts

Click for Router Charts

Router Ranker

Click for Router Ranker

NAS Charts

Click for NAS Charts

NAS Ranker

Click for NAS Ranker

More Tools

Click for More Tools

NAS Basics

Choosing a Format

If you go the attached-drive route, you may have a choice of formatting for it, as noted above. The most widely-supported format is FAT32, since it allows a drive to be moved between the NAS and Windows systems. But FAT32 isn't an attractive option for many home media collectors, since it can't handle individual files over 4 GB and Windows won't present the FAT32 format option for drives larger than 32 GB (explanation).

If you're ok with the file size limit, there are ways to format drives up to 2 TB. I used fat32format.exe from Ridgecrop Consultants to format a 60 GB USB drive. You'll need to use the Windows Disk Management utility (Start > Programs > Administrative Tools > Computer Management or right-click on My Computer and choose Manage) to delete any existing partitions and create an unformatted primary partition first, however. If you prefer a GUI-based application, you can use SwissKnife from CompuApps. Both are free.

A better solution is to use the same format used on your NAS' internal drive, if your NAS offers that formatting option. This will most likely result in the best performance and you won't have to deal with FAT32's pesky file size limit.

Since most NASes run some form of open-source OS, these formats include ext2/3, XFS, HFS+, UFS and reiserfs. Most NASes that support external backup include the ability to format the external drive. But you might not get a choice of format, or even an indication of the format is being used.

For example, WD's refreshed MyBook World is supposed to support read and write to drives formatted in FAT32, HFS+, ext3 and NTFS. But I was only able to successfully back up to an NTFS-formatted drive, since its internal FAT32 format utiility failed.

Buffalo's new LinkStation Pro XHL is more flexible and can format and read and write to USB drives with FAT32, ext3 or its native XFS. It also supports NTFS, but read-only. In fact, read-only support for NTFS is usually the norm and is mostly likely due to extremely poor NTFS write performance.

The issue of slow NTFS backup performance was first raised in the QNAP forum and this discussion seems to indicate the use of a free NTFS driver as the culprit. But QNAP is not alone in low NTFS performance. For example, I was able to achieve only 1.47 MB/s backing up to an NTFS-formatted USB drive with the new WD MyBook World.

Of course, if you format the external drive in something other than FAT32 (or NTFS), you won't be able to read it on your Windows system. Fortunately, it's relatively easy to add ext2/3 read/write (but not formatting) capability to Windows via EXT2IFS. It installs as a driver and works with NT4.0/2000/XP/2003/Vista/2008.

Support for reading and writing other formats in Windows requires more work. This article describes using colinux to access ext3, reiserfs or XFS partitions. The process is somewhat involved, however, and not for newbies. You might have better luck using a live CD of the open source distro of your choice to mount drives formatted with filesystems other than ext2/3. Ubuntu is a popular choice, with support for many filesystems.

You should only have to do this as recovery measure anyway, in the rare event that both of your NASes die. One of the main reasons for taking the NAS-to-NAS backup approach vs. RAID is simplification of backup and recovery. If only one NAS dies, you at most lose only the files created or modified since the last backup. And those should be safe and snug on the primary NAS, awaiting the swap in of a replacement NAS and a fresh full backup.

To The Cloud

Even if you avoid the backup land mines and successfully set up an automatic backup that runs multiple times per day, you're still not out of the woods. Consider what would happen to your data should your home be burglarized and both of your NASes stolen? Or if you had a fire or other disaster that ruined both drives?

Fortunately, the NAS industry is slowly integrating online or "cloud" backup options into NASes. The revamped (and Windows Home Server based) HP MediaSmart Server includes an option to back up to Amazon S3 and NETGEAR recently rolled out its ReadyNAS Vault service (which uses ElephantDrive). I would expect to see Iomega, whose parent company also owns the Mozy online backup service, integrate it into at least some of its NASes pretty soon. The ix2 seems the most likely candidate, since it has received a few other upgrades.

Closing Thoughts

I have only scratched the surface of a NAS feature set that should get much more attention from both NAS vendors and buyers. But despite its shortcomings, I still think that automatic NAS-to-NAS backup multiple times a day is the way to go for most home and many small business users. Once you have the right products, it's simple to set up, easy to recover and can grow with you as your storage needs expand.

I just hope that more NAS vendors understand the value of this approach and follow NETGEAR's lead in moving away from limited, proprietary methods to offering as many ways as possible to help us simply and reliably keep our precious data backed up.

More Basics

Wi-Fi System Tools
Check out our Wi-Fi System Charts, Ranker and Finder!

Support Us!

If you like what we do and want to thank us, just buy something on Amazon. We'll get a small commission on anything you buy. Thanks!

Over In The Forums

Hi, Brand new RT-AC86U to upgrade from RT-AC66U. I put the most recent Merlin firmware on it (not Beta). I connect directly to the ONT (no Centurylink...
Sorry for the horrible image/drawing. If you all still don't understand what i want to do it is ok.
Hi everyone,Basically, the title says it all.Some details:AX88u as main router, hw revision 1.1, latest Merlin firmware 384.14AC86u as Aimesh node, hw...
My log looks alot diffrent then normal and I saw something about user nobody so dropping root privileges. So hoping someone that knows more then me ca...
HiI have first tried getting support from Asus, but that is like getting blood out of a stone!My new Asus router just will not connect to a web browse...

Don't Miss These

  • 1
  • 2
  • 3